All Conference First Team
- Goalie, Mason Spurlin* Stevens Point, 12
- Defenseman, Tyler Loomis* Stevens Point, 12
- Defenseman, Carter Morrison* Wis. Rapids Lincoln, 12
- Forward, Jackson Schroeder* Stevens Point, 11
- Forward, Carsen Gause* Wis. Rapids Lincoln, 12
- Forward, Grady Miller, Stevens Point, 10
*=denotes unanimous selection.
Valley Player of the Year
Carson Gause, Wisconsin Rapids Lincoln
Second Team
- Goalie, Parks Guenther, Wausau West, 12
- Defenseman, Jamie Reeve, Stevens Point, 12
- Defenseman, Tyson Vilbaum, Wis. Rapids Lincoln, 11
- Forward, Josh Dekarske, Wis. Rapids Lincoln, 12
- Forward, Cooper Depuydt, Wausau West, 10
- Forward, Thomas Passineau, D.C. Everest, 11
Honorable Mention
- Goalie, Griffen Bunnell, D.C. Everest, 10
- Defenseman, Thomas Cashmer, Marshfield, 12
- Defenseman, Grant Wincentsen, Wausau West, 12
- Defenseman, Logan Ostricki, Stevens Point, 10
- Forward, Caden Bohlin, Wausau West, 11
- Forward, Grant Molski, Stevens Point, 10
- Forward, Hendrix Damrow, Wausau West, 10
- Forward, Zach Pagel, Merrill/Newman/Wausau East, 11
NOTES: Carsen Gause was a unanimous first team selection in 2022-23 and a second team selection the previous two seasons; Jackson Schroeder was a first team selection in 2022-23 and an honorable mention selection in 2021-22; Carter Morrison and Parks Guenther were second team selections in 2022-23; Josh Dekarske was a second team selection in 2022-23 and an honorable mention selection in 2021-22; Zach Pagel and Cooper Depuydt were honorable mention selections in 2022-23
